STORMO! Forum Index


STORMO! Forum Index

Reply to topic
Sgt.Salvadori's Cr.42
SuperAereo
Banned

Joined: 29 May 2007
Posts: 9
Location: London UK
Reply with quote
I was recently reading "modeldad"'s article on the Fiat Cr.42 piloted by Sgt. Pietro Salvadori, who made an emergency landing at Orfordness (http://www.stormomagazine.com/Re-evalatuating_RA_Camo_1940.html), and I would tend to dissent with the idea that the uppersurfaces were originally painted in only two colours.

If we confront this photograph:



with this one:



We can clearly see how the darker colour in the camouflage was not affected by a repainting, and that the supposed "repainting" in Dark Earth has been done with a spraygun, leaving very blurry edges. If the colour had been sprayed by the RAF, it would surely have been oversprayed over the darker areas, something which clearly did not happen.

I believe that the plane was painted in the standard Fiat camouflage of Verde Mimetico 3 and Marrone Mimetico 2 on a Giallo Mimetico 3 background: the normal practice for the RAF anyway would have been to repaint the entire uppersurfaces in the Temperate Land Scheme of Dark Green and Dark Earth, certainly not to modify a pre-existing camouflage scheme.

The almost invisibility of the second camouflage colour in the first photo can easily be explained by light conditions, type of film used or the use of a yellow filter, which would have blended the Marrone Mimetico with the Giallo Mimetico, giving the mistaken impression of a 2-colour scheme.

Wartime British crash reports are notoriously unreliable when it comes to the description of the camouflage of downed enemy planes, in time of war the attention was obviously more focused on the technical characteristics of the machines, such as armament and the presence of armour, so it is no surprise that the mottled camouflage of MM.5701 should have been hastily described as having "greenish-yellow blotches".

The second photograph is a scan from a cheap volume published by Grange Press in the UK, the kind of volume normally found in discount bookstores, and I have so far been unable to ascertain its provenience, even if it is probably in the IWM or RAF Museum collection. Inquries with the publisher have received no response, I am sorry to report, but the absence of overspray leaves no doubts in my mind that the original camouflage had been left intact (the shapes in the darker colour are consistantly the same in both photos) and that it was indeed tha standard Fiat 3-colour scheme.
View user's profileSend private messageFind all posts by SuperAereo
Editor
Site Admin
Site Admin

Joined: 24 Jul 2003
Posts: 1864
Location: Calgary, AB, CANADA
Reply with quote
This is a great post. The second photo is a very interesting artifact since the dark shade mottles in the sketch match exactly the shape and form of those in the photo. We do know that the C2 camo scheme did show up on a batch of CR.42s at about the same time as the CR.42s that were sent to Belgium, however the sketch seems to suggest this batch of planes were not used over the English Channel. It would be nice to confirm the origins of the sketch. A very interesting post! Thank you.

_________________
Vince Tassone
View user's profileSend private messageSend e-mailVisit poster's websiteFind all posts by Editor
Unseen colors
D520
Generale di Divisone Aerea
Generale di Divisone Aerea

Joined: 04 Nov 2006
Posts: 434
Location: St Sever. landes
Reply with quote
Well, as a matter of fact we are facing a film reaction to certain shades, and as we all know, this fact has led to some misinterpretations in the camouflages of some planes. Italian camouflages , at the begining of the conflict were known to be of three colors; most of the time the background was to be a sand color, 1,2,3,4 and a mixture of blotches of green 1,2,3 and brown. The recurrent possibility of this background to be a light green has never been so far proven; R. Caruana was estimating that the green background could be the result of the spray of the green over the Giallo.
To go back to the pics of the Fiat CR-42, we are facing the same problem than with the G-50 sold to Finland. For about 30 years they were sand and green because the films with which the pictures were taken did not shown the marrone blotches! It must be understood that, despite an unclear directives from the Statio Maggiore, planes for the RA and for the Finnish were painted the same. For the CR-42 from the 162 squadr., based in Rhodes if I remember well, I do not see why those rules should have changed, and why a spray of green should have been applied.
I am open to any suggestion, but I sincerly doubt about a new scheme.
Best regards, jean.
View user's profileSend private messageSend e-mailFind all posts by D520
Sgt.Salvadori's Cr.42
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
All times are GMT - 7 Hours  
Page 1 of 1  

  
  
 Reply to topic  



Please contact me with any questions or suggestions
webm...@stormomagazine.com